Skip to header Skip to main navigation Skip to main content Skip to footer

Search form

Home
Eagle Nest New Mexico
Where the Mountains Meet the Lake

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Dining
  • Lodging
  • Shopping
  • Things to Do
  • Outdoors
  • History
  • Webcams
  • Business Directory

Thirty Years Before the Water Rose: The Long Wait for Eagle Nest Lake

Eagle Nest Lake seen across the grassland of the Moreno Valley floor, with a forested mountain rising behind the water.

When you stand on the shore at Eagle Nest Lake State Park, the water looks as if it has always belonged here. The lake spreads about five miles long and two miles wide across the Moreno Valley floor, its surface sitting at 8,172 feet when full, beneath Wheeler Peak and Baldy Mountain. Yet this lake was imagined for thirty years before the water rose, and the valley floor it covers was working farmland whose owners did not give it up easily.

Click to see more photos of Eagle Nest Lake

The idea itself was an old one. The National Register nomination for Eagle Nest Dam records that in 1888 a surveyor named Levi Preston surmised that a dam one hundred feet high, built where the Cimarron River departed the Moreno Valley, would collect enough water to irrigate 54,000 acres. In 1906 Charles Springer bought a six hundred acre dam site from the Maxwell Land Grant Company, and in 1907 Frank and Charles Springer and the Cimarron Valley Land Company were granted Permit No. 71 to impound the Cimarron River for irrigation.

A permit, however, could not flood a farm by itself. The land destined to lie under the new lake belonged in large part to Mary Gallagher, a widow with eight children. Her husband John had bought the property with proceeds from his gold mining days at Elizabethtown in the 1870s, and he had dug canals from both Willow Creek and Cieneguilla Creek to irrigate his crops. In January 1908 Mary filed a formal protest against the dam proposal. The State Engineer approved the permit in early July of that year, and the company began negotiating with the three property owners affected, but Mary Gallagher held out.

In April 1909 the Cimarron Valley Land Company filed a lawsuit to condemn her land, and the real delays began. At first there was no judge in the county to take up the matter, and once that issue was resolved the proceedings still moved slowly, through appeals, a demand for a jury trial, and a commission established to determine the value of the property. The process did not formally end until after Mary Gallagher died in 1916. When the company had asked in April 1915 for an extension of its permit, it cited unprecedented financial conditions and did not mention the condemnation suit at all.

The deeds for the condemned lands were handed over on January 17, 1917, after her children had been paid, and construction on the dam and reservoir at the head of Cimarron Canyon finally got underway in March of that year. Even with wartime shortages of material, equipment, and labor, the dam was ninety percent complete by the middle of December 1917. When the finished dam impounded the Cimarron River in 1918, the water backed up over the meadow and farmland of the valley floor and created a lake of about 2,500 acres, holding 79,120 acre-feet of water for farms far downstream.

That is the quiet truth beneath the surface our visitors fish and boat on today. Under Eagle Nest Lake lies a Moreno Valley farm, with its irrigation canals and its protest letters still preserved in the Permit No. 71 record. The lake is a reservoir, a park, and a mountain landmark, but it is also the end of a thirty-year wait that began with a surveyor's guess in 1888 and turned on one family's refusal to leave the valley floor.

Eagle Nest Lake
Eagle Nest Dam
Eagle Nest History
Moreno Valley
New Mexico History
Eagle Nest Lake State Park
Ranching History

Eagle Nest, NM Weather

Loading current conditions...

Loading forecast...

Upcoming Events

🎉 Eagle Nest Events Calendar

Annual Favorites:
Fourth of July Parade, Barbecue, and Fireworks over the Lake
High Country Arts Festival — Late July, Enchanted Eagle Park
BalloonFest over Eagle Nest Lake
Fish Fest and Pike Round-Up — September, Eagle Nest Lake State Park

Article Archive

Browse past articles