Skip to header Skip to main navigation Skip to main content Skip to footer

Search form

Home
Eagle Nest New Mexico
Where the Mountains Meet the Lake

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Dining
  • Lodging
  • Shopping
  • Things to Do
  • Outdoors
  • History
  • Webcams
  • Business Directory

The Mutz Hotel: The Stone Ruin That Remembers Elizabethtown

The stone ruins of the Mutz Hotel in Elizabethtown, New Mexico, photographed in 2004 by Dave Alexander.

Every ghost town has one building that carries its memory, and in Elizabethtown it is the Mutz Hotel. Or rather, what is left of it: a few low stone walls and tall window openings standing in the grass above NM 38, five miles north of Eagle Nest, photographed by nearly every traveler who stops. The ruin's story is the town's story in miniature: built on confidence, burned in a night, rebuilt in stone, and finally left to the wind.

The hotel was the work of Herman Mutz, a rancher and cattleman who bet on Elizabethtown's future when the mining town still had one. The first Mutz Hotel was a wooden building, like most of E-Town, and it shared wooden E-Town's fate. In 1903 a fire that started in the Remsberg Store swept the business district. When it burned out, Herman Froelick's store was the only business left standing, and the Mutz Hotel was ash.

Mutz rebuilt, and this time he built in stone. The second Mutz Hotel was meant to be fireproof, permanent, a statement that Elizabethtown intended to last. It was a reasonable bet placed at an unreasonable moment. The mines were fading, the young men were leaving for newer booms, and by 1917 the town that had once been New Mexico's first incorporated municipality was nearly empty. A stone hotel without travelers is just a building waiting to become a ruin, and the Mutz became a handsome one.

What remains today rewards the stop. Froelick's Store, the fire's lone survivor, still stands nearby, and the town's church was rebuilt, but it is the Mutz walls that draw the cameras: two stories of window arches with nothing behind them but sky and Baldy Mountain. Elizabeth Moore, the little girl the town was named for, lived in Elizabethtown her whole life and is buried in its cemetery. She watched the Mutz rise, burn, rise again, and empty. The walls she knew are the ones we photograph.

Stand there at the golden hour and the ruin stops looking like a failure. It looks like what it is: the most durable sentence left in a town that wrote its history in gold, wood, fire, and stone.

Elizabethtown
Eagle Nest History
Moreno Valley
New Mexico History
Gold Rush

Eagle Nest, NM Weather

Loading current conditions...

Loading forecast...

Upcoming Events

🎉 Eagle Nest Events Calendar

Annual Favorites:
Fourth of July Parade, Barbecue, and Fireworks over the Lake
High Country Arts Festival — Late July, Enchanted Eagle Park
BalloonFest over Eagle Nest Lake
Fish Fest and Pike Round-Up — September, Eagle Nest Lake State Park

Article Archive

Browse past articles