Skip to header Skip to main navigation Skip to main content Skip to footer

Search form

Home
Eagle Nest New Mexico
Where the Mountains Meet the Lake

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Dining
  • Lodging
  • Shopping
  • Things to Do
  • Outdoors
  • History
  • Webcams
  • Business Directory

Elizabethtown: The Gold-Rush Boomtown Above Eagle Nest

The stone ruins of the Mutz Hotel in Elizabethtown, New Mexico, all that remains of the gold-rush boomtown.

Five miles north of Eagle Nest, a few stone walls and a hillside cemetery are all that remain of the town that started everything in the Moreno Valley. Elizabethtown began in 1866, when gold was found in the gravel of Willow Creek on the slopes of Baldy Mountain. Word of the strike spread the way word of gold always does, and within months a tent city of miners was climbing the canyon.

The town took its name from a child. Captain William H. Moore, a founder of the settlement, named it for his four-year-old daughter, Elizabeth. The little girl's name went onto the plat of what became, in 1868, the first incorporated town in New Mexico — an honor that surprises people who assume Santa Fe or Albuquerque came first. By 1869 Elizabethtown had roughly a hundred buildings: stores, saloons, hotels, a school, and the stamp mills that crushed ore from the mines above town.

The Aztec mine, the district's richest producer, ran a fifteen-stamp mill and in its best weeks yielded up to 21,000 dollars in gold. Sawmills in the canyons cut lumber as fast as the boom could nail it together, and the town briefly served as the seat of Colfax County. Photographs from those years show a real city: false-front stores along a muddy main street, freight wagons, and a population that some estimates put in the thousands.

Booms, though, are called booms because of what follows. The easy gold played out, litigation and lean years idled the mines, and in 1872 the county seat moved to Cimarron, taking the lawyers, the records, and much of the reason to stay. Fires and departures thinned the town over the following decades. A fire in 1903 took most of the wooden buildings, and by 1917 Elizabethtown was nearly empty.

What survives is worth the short drive from Eagle Nest: the stone ruins of the Mutz Hotel, Herman Froelick's store still standing, a rebuilt church, and the cemetery on the hill where Elizabeth Moore herself was laid to rest in 1937. Stand there at dusk, with Baldy Mountain turning gold above the empty streets, and the Moreno Valley's first city does not feel entirely gone.

Elizabethtown
Gold Rush
Eagle Nest History
Moreno Valley
New Mexico History
Colfax County

Eagle Nest, NM Weather

Loading current conditions...

Loading forecast...

Upcoming Events

🎉 Eagle Nest Events Calendar

Annual Favorites:
Fourth of July Parade, Barbecue, and Fireworks over the Lake
High Country Arts Festival — Late July, Enchanted Eagle Park
BalloonFest over Eagle Nest Lake
Fish Fest and Pike Round-Up — September, Eagle Nest Lake State Park

Article Archive

Browse past articles