Most towns come first and acquire their landmarks later. Eagle Nest did it backwards: the landmark came first, and the town was established in 1920 to stand beside it. That was the year Eagle Nest Dam, after years of construction delayed by a world war and two killing winters, was finally completed in Cimarron Canyon. Behind the arch, the Cimarron River began spreading into a five-mile lake, and at the lake's north end a brand-new settlement took shape: Therma, the village that would become Eagle Nest.
The setting explains the ambition. The Moreno Valley of western Colfax County lies at 8,216 feet, a high, wide bowl of grassland between the Cimarron Range and the Sangre de Cristo Mountains. Before 1920 it was ranch and farm country, served by the old mining town of Elizabethtown five miles north and by scattered homesteads. What it lacked was a town at the water, and the new lake supplied the reason to build one: irrigation farmers needing supplies, fishermen discovering the stocked lake, and travelers crossing the valley all needed a place to stop.
Therma was that place. Its founders laid it out along the road that is now Therma Drive, and the village took its first name from the Greek word for hot, a hopeful label for a town where the lake wind keeps winters honest. Through the 1920s it grew the way lake towns do, a store at a time, a cabin court at a time, in step with the seasons of water and visitors.
In the 1930s the village traded its classical name for the one the country offered: Eagle Nest, for the golden eagles of the canyon and the dam and lake that already bore the name. The old word survived where it mattered most, in the name of the main street.
A town founded beside a construction project could easily have vanished when the crews left. Instead, the lake stayed, the fish grew, and the village endured. Every summer morning when the water is glass and the eagles work the shoreline, Eagle Nest still looks like what it was in 1920: a new town at the edge of a new lake, in one of the prettiest valleys in New Mexico.