Skip to header Skip to main navigation Skip to main content Skip to footer

Search form

Home
Eagle Nest New Mexico
Where the Mountains Meet the Lake

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Dining
  • Lodging
  • Shopping
  • Things to Do
  • Outdoors
  • History
  • Webcams
  • Business Directory

The Minister in Cimarron Canyon: The Maxwell Grant and the Colfax County War

The facade of the St. James Hotel in Cimarron, New Mexico, where Francisco Griego confronted Clay Allison in 1875

Did you know that the quiet Moreno Valley, where Eagle Nest sits today, once lay inside the largest private land grant in United States history, and that a fight over who owned that land turned deadly in the canyon just west of town? The Maxwell Land Grant began in 1841, when Mexican governor Manuel Armijo granted some 1,714,765 acres in what is now Colfax County, New Mexico, and southern Colorado to Charles Beaubien and Guadalupe Miranda. Elizabethtown, Baldy Mountain, and the whole Moreno Valley were inside its boundaries.

Click to see more photos of Cimarron and the Maxwell Land Grant country — the St. James Hotel, the Aztec Mill, and Cimarron Canyon

Beaubien's son-in-law, Lucien B. Maxwell, bought out the other heirs after Beaubien died in 1864 and ran the grant with a famously loose hand. Settlers, ranchers, and miners were often allowed to live and work on grant land on little more than his word. That changed in 1870, when Maxwell sold the grant and the new owners formed the Maxwell Land Grant and Railway Company. The company demanded rent and tried to remove families who believed the land was public domain, or who trusted Maxwell's unwritten permission. Settlers met on March 30, 1873, and agreed to arm themselves to defend their homes, and that same year the U.S. Department of the Interior ordered much of the grant treated as public land, deepening the confusion over who truly owned what.

Into that standoff rode the Reverend Franklin J. Tolby, a 33-year-old Methodist minister who quickly sided with the settlers. Tolby spoke against the company and the powerful Santa Fe Ring of politicians and lawyers allied with it, and he sent letters to the New York Sun exposing what he saw as corrupt methods. On September 14, 1875, Tolby was shot in Cimarron Canyon, near Clear Creek, midway on the road between Elizabethtown and Cimarron, the same winding canyon road visitors drive today between Eagle Nest and Cimarron. His murder is widely remembered as the spark that turned a land dispute into the Colfax County War.

The weeks that followed were grim. Cruz Vega, a nephew of Hispanic settler leader Francisco Griego, was implicated in Tolby's killing and was hanged by a mob led by gunman Clay Allison. On November 1, 1875, Griego confronted Allison in the saloon of the St. James Hotel in Cimarron and was shot dead; the killing was later ruled self-defense. A man named Cardenas then confessed to Tolby's murder and was hanged on November 10. Tolby's fellow minister, Oscar Patrick McMains, took up the settlers' cause and kept the fight in the courts and in public for years afterward.

The conflict dragged on, in one form or another, until 1888. The English owners foreclosed in 1879 and Dutch owners took over, but the legal question outlived them all. In April 1887 the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the grant, ruling that it was valid and that its survey and patent were entirely free from fraud. Many settlers left; some settled with the company and stayed. Today the valley is peaceful ranch and recreation country, but drive west from Eagle Nest through Cimarron Canyon, past Clear Creek, and you are traveling the very road where a dispute over a line on a map became one of New Mexico's most violent chapters.

Maxwell Land Grant
Eagle Nest History
New Mexico History
Colfax County
Elizabethtown
Moreno Valley
Eagle Nest New Mexico

Eagle Nest, NM Weather

Loading current conditions...

Loading forecast...

Upcoming Events

🎉 Eagle Nest Events Calendar

Annual Favorites:
Fourth of July Parade, Barbecue, and Fireworks over the Lake
High Country Arts Festival — Late July, Enchanted Eagle Park
BalloonFest over Eagle Nest Lake
Fish Fest and Pike Round-Up — September, Eagle Nest Lake State Park

Article Archive

Browse past articles